Technology gives employers more ways than ever to monitor how work is carried out. Businesses may use CCTV, email monitoring, internet usage records, location tracking, access controls or software that measures activity and productivity.
There can be legitimate reasons for workplace monitoring, including protecting confidential information, preventing fraud, ensuring health and safety or investigating misconduct. However, employers also need to respect employee privacy and comply with data protection law.
Monitoring should therefore have a clear purpose, be proportionate to the risk being addressed and be communicated properly to employees.
Can employers legally monitor employees?
Yes, workplace monitoring can be lawful, but employers do not have an unrestricted right to monitor employees simply because they own the equipment or systems being used.
The Information Commissioner’s Office (ICO) says employers must balance their business interests against workers’ privacy rights and use the least intrusive method reasonably available to achieve their purpose.
Before introducing monitoring, employers should be clear about:
- Why monitoring is necessary
- What information will be collected
- Who will be monitored
- How the information will be used
- Who will have access to it
- How long it will be retained
- Whether a less intrusive approach could achieve the same result.
Monitoring employees “just in case” without a clear purpose is unlikely to be appropriate.
Employers need a lawful basis
Employee monitoring usually involves processing personal data, so employers need to identify an appropriate lawful basis under data protection law.
Depending on the circumstances, this might involve legitimate interests, compliance with a legal obligation or another appropriate basis.
Employers should be cautious about relying on employee consent. Because of the imbalance of power within an employment relationship, the ICO says consent will not usually be appropriate unless employees have a genuine choice without suffering any disadvantage.
Where monitoring is likely to capture particularly sensitive information, additional requirements apply.
Be transparent with employees
Employees should generally understand that monitoring is taking place and why.
A workplace monitoring or acceptable use policy can explain:
- What monitoring the business carries out
- The reasons for monitoring
- Which systems or devices are covered
- How information may be used
- Who may see the information
- What employees can reasonably expect when using workplace systems.
Privacy information should also clearly explain how personal data collected through monitoring is handled.
Simply including broad monitoring rights in an employment contract will not necessarily make monitoring lawful or proportionate.
When is a Data Protection Impact Assessment needed?
A Data Protection Impact Assessment (DPIA) helps employers identify and reduce privacy risks before introducing monitoring.
The ICO recommends considering a DPIA whenever workplace monitoring is proposed and requires one where the processing is likely to result in a high risk to individuals’ rights and freedoms. Where a DPIA identifies a high risk that cannot be reduced, an employer must consult the ICO before proceeding.
Certain forms of monitoring can be particularly intrusive. For example, the ICO specifically says employers considering monitoring the content of emails and messages should complete a DPIA because of the potential impact on workers’ privacy.
Carrying out the assessment before introducing new technology can also help employers determine whether a less intrusive solution is available.
Can employers monitor emails and messages?
Employers may have legitimate reasons to monitor work email or messaging systems, such as protecting confidential information, detecting security threats or investigating suspected misconduct.
However, monitoring the content of communications is significantly more intrusive than monitoring basic usage information.
Employers should therefore consider whether their objective could be achieved by reviewing information such as network traffic, access logs or email metadata rather than reading message content.
The ICO advises that employees should be told in advance where content monitoring may take place and the circumstances in which it could happen.
What about CCTV in the workplace?
CCTV may be used for purposes such as security, preventing theft or protecting employees and visitors.
Employers should be clear about why cameras are needed and position them so that they do not capture more information than necessary.
Monitoring areas where employees would reasonably expect a high degree of privacy is particularly difficult to justify.
Appropriate signage and privacy information should normally explain that CCTV is operating and why.
Monitoring remote and hybrid workers
Remote working has increased the use of productivity monitoring, device tracking and other technology designed to measure employee activity.
However, employees working from home generally have a greater expectation of privacy than they would in a traditional workplace. Monitoring can also inadvertently capture information about family members or an employee’s private life.
Highly intrusive practices such as continuous webcam monitoring, screenshots or detailed keystroke tracking are likely to require particularly strong justification.
Employers should ask whether outputs, performance objectives or less intrusive system information could achieve the same aim.
Can monitoring information be used in disciplinary proceedings?
Potentially, but employers should consider how the information was obtained and whether employees were told it could be used for that purpose.
For example, information collected for cyber security purposes should not automatically be used for unrelated performance monitoring without considering the data protection implications.
Employers should also ensure that monitoring evidence is considered fairly and alongside other relevant information before disciplinary decisions are made.
What about AI and automated monitoring tools?
Some workplace monitoring systems use algorithms or AI to assess productivity, attendance, behaviour or performance.
Employers should understand how these systems reach conclusions and ensure that automated outputs are not treated as automatically reliable.
Where monitoring feeds into automated decisions with significant effects on employees, additional data protection requirements can apply. The ICO also emphasises the importance of meaningful human involvement where automated tools are used.
Review monitoring arrangements regularly
A monitoring system that was proportionate when introduced may not remain necessary indefinitely.
Employers should periodically review:
- Whether the original purpose still exists
- Whether the monitoring remains proportionate
- Whether less intrusive technology is now available
- Who can access monitoring data
- How long information is retained
- Whether policies and privacy notices remain accurate.
New monitoring technology should also be reviewed before implementation rather than simply switched on because the functionality is available.
Getting workplace monitoring right
Effective workplace monitoring should protect legitimate business interests without unnecessarily intruding into employees’ private lives.
Clear objectives, appropriate policies and proportionate monitoring can help employers manage business risk while maintaining employee trust and complying with data protection requirements.
DTM Legal’s Employment & HR team advises employers on employee privacy, workplace monitoring, data protection policies and the use of monitoring information in workplace investigations and disciplinary processes.
If your business is introducing workplace monitoring, reviewing its employee privacy arrangements or dealing with an issue involving monitoring data, contact DTM Legal’s Employment & HR team to discuss how we can help.