Businesses increasingly use a mixture of permanent employees, casual workers, consultants, freelancers and self-employed contractors. While this can provide flexibility, it also makes it important to understand the employment status of the people working for your organisation.
Employment status determines many of the rights an individual has and the responsibilities an employer owes to them. Getting it wrong can lead to claims for unpaid holiday pay, National Minimum Wage, employment rights and, in some circumstances, tax liabilities and penalties.
Importantly, calling someone “self-employed” in a contract does not necessarily make them self-employed in law. The reality of the working relationship will be crucial when determining their employment status.
What are the main types of employment status?
For employment rights purposes, there are three main categories to understand:
- Employee
- Worker
- Self-employed contractor
The distinction matters because each category comes with different rights and responsibilities.
What is an employee?
An employee generally works under a contract of employment and has the widest range of statutory employment rights.
Depending on the relevant eligibility requirements, these can include rights relating to:
- Paid holiday
- National Minimum Wage
- Statutory family leave and pay
- Statutory Sick Pay
- Minimum notice
- Statutory redundancy pay
- Protection from unfair dismissal
- Protection from discrimination and unlawful deductions from wages.
Employees will often work within a relatively structured relationship, with the employer exercising significant control over when, where and how their work is carried out.
What is a worker?
A worker sits between an employee and someone who is genuinely self-employed.
Workers do not generally have all the rights available to employees, but they do have important statutory protections.
These include rights such as:
- National Minimum Wage
- Paid annual leave
- Rest breaks
- Protection against unlawful deductions from wages
- Protection from discrimination
- Whistleblowing protection.
Someone may therefore be described as a casual worker, freelancer or contractor but still qualify as a worker and gain these rights.
What does self-employed mean?
Someone who is genuinely self-employed will normally be running their own business and providing services to customers or clients.
They typically have more independence over how they carry out their work and may take greater financial risk.
A genuinely self-employed contractor will not normally receive the same statutory employment rights as employees or workers.
However, simply paying someone through invoices or describing them as a contractor is not enough to establish self-employed status.
How is employment status decided?
There is no single test that determines employment status.
Courts and employment tribunals will consider the overall relationship between the individual and the organisation. Government guidance confirms that status is determined by the facts and circumstances of the working arrangement rather than simply what the parties decide to call it.
Relevant factors can include:
Personal service
Is the individual expected to carry out the work personally, or do they have a genuine ability to send someone else in their place?
A requirement for personal service can point towards worker or employee status.
Control
How much control does the organisation exercise?
This might include deciding:
- What work is carried out
- When it is completed
- Where the individual works
- How the work should be performed.
Greater levels of control can indicate an employment relationship.
Mutual obligations
The relationship between the parties will also be considered.
For example, is the business expected to provide work and is the individual expected to accept and perform it?
How integrated is the individual?
An individual who operates as part of the organisation may be more likely to have employee or worker status than an independent business providing services to a customer.
Factors such as using company equipment, being managed alongside employees or being subject to internal procedures may all be relevant.
Financial risk and independence
Someone who operates their own business, works for several clients, provides their own equipment and carries genuine financial risk may be more likely to be self-employed.
No single factor will necessarily decide the outcome.
Why is the written contract not enough?
A well-drafted contract is important, but it needs to reflect what actually happens in practice.
For example, a contract might describe an individual as an independent contractor and say that they can provide a substitute.
If, in reality, they are required to work personally, follow the company’s instructions and operate in the same way as employees, the contractual label may carry limited weight.
Employers should therefore review both the written agreement and the day-to-day working arrangements.
What are the risks of getting employment status wrong?
Misclassification can create significant financial and legal exposure.
Someone treated as self-employed might successfully establish that they were actually a worker and pursue claims for rights such as unpaid holiday pay or National Minimum Wage.
If they qualify as an employee, additional employment rights may apply.
Employment status can also affect tax and National Insurance. However, the tests for employment rights and tax are separate, meaning an individual’s tax status will not necessarily determine their employment law status.
HMRC provides its Check Employment Status for Tax (CEST) service to give an indication on status for tax and National Insurance purposes.
When should employers review employment status?
Employment status should not necessarily be assessed once and then forgotten.
A review may be appropriate where:
- A contractor has worked for the business for a long period
- Working arrangements have changed
- The organisation is increasing its use of freelancers or consultants
- Contractors are performing similar roles to employees
- A business is restructuring its workforce
- An individual challenges their employment status.
Government guidance recommends that employers keep employment status under review because working relationships can change over time.
Reducing employment status risk
Businesses should ensure that contracts accurately reflect how working relationships operate in practice.
Where there is uncertainty, reviewing arrangements before a dispute arises can help identify potential exposure and allow the business to make informed changes.
DTM Legal’s Employment & HR team advises employers on employment status, contractor and worker arrangements and disputes concerning employee, worker and self-employed status.
If you are unsure about the employment status of people working within your business or are facing an employment status dispute, contact DTM Legal’s Employment & HR team to discuss your position.