When a director or shareholder leaves a business, the process can be more complicated than an ordinary employee departure.
A senior individual may simultaneously be an employee, a statutory director and a shareholder. Ending one of those relationships does not automatically bring the others to an end.
Understand the different roles involved
The first step is to establish exactly what roles the individual holds.
They may be:
- An employee under a contract of employment
- A director registered at Companies House
- A shareholder
- A party to a shareholders’ agreement
- A member of a partnership or LLP
- A guarantor of company obligations.
These roles have different legal consequences.
For example, terminating a director’s employment does not necessarily remove them from the board or require them to give up their shares. Each part of the relationship therefore needs to be considered separately.
Review the director’s service agreement
Where the individual is employed by the company, their service agreement or employment contract should be reviewed before any exit is proposed.
Important provisions may include:
- Notice periods
- Payment in lieu of notice
- Garden leave
- Bonus and commission arrangements
- Benefits
- Confidentiality
- Restrictive covenants
- Intellectual property obligations
- Termination provisions.
The employer should also consider the individual’s statutory employment rights, including whether there is a potential risk of an unfair dismissal, discrimination or whistleblowing claim.
Removing someone as a director
Ending employment does not automatically remove someone as a statutory director.
A director may resign voluntarily, or there may be provisions within the company’s articles dealing with when their appointment ends.
Under the Companies Act 2006, shareholders can also remove a director by ordinary resolution at a meeting, although special notice and specific procedural requirements apply. Removing a director does not necessarily remove any separate contractual rights they may have as an employee or office-holder.
The company should therefore consider both the corporate and employment law position before taking action.
What happens to the director’s shares?
A director or employee who leaves the business does not automatically stop being a shareholder.
The company’s articles of association and any shareholders’ agreement should be checked for provisions dealing with departing shareholders.
These may contain leaver provisions requiring shares to be offered for sale when someone’s employment or directorship ends.
They may also distinguish between a “good leaver” and “bad leaver”, with different rules for how the shares are valued depending on the circumstances of departure.
Where no compulsory transfer provisions exist, the departing individual may be entitled to retain their shares.
Consider how the shares will be valued
Where shares are being transferred as part of the exit, the valuation mechanism can become an important issue.
The shareholders’ agreement or articles may specify how the price is calculated.
This could involve:
- Market value
- An independent valuation
- A formula based on company performance
- A discounted value in specified circumstances
- A nominal amount for certain bad-leaver situations.
Disagreements over valuation can quickly become contentious, so the contractual provisions should be reviewed before negotiations begin.
Could a settlement agreement help?
A settlement agreement can provide a useful way to document an agreed director or shareholder exit.
Depending on the circumstances, it might cover:
- Termination of employment
- Notice and termination payments
- Resignation from directorships
- Transfer or sale of shares
- Bonus or incentive arrangements
- Confidentiality
- Restrictive covenants
- Return of company property
- Announcements about the departure
- Waiver of employment claims.
For the settlement agreement to validly waive statutory employment claims, the individual must receive independent legal advice.
Where share transfers or corporate changes are also involved, additional documents may be required alongside the employment settlement.
Protect confidential information and business relationships
Senior directors and shareholders often have access to commercially sensitive information and important customer, supplier or employee relationships.
The company should review any confidentiality and restrictive covenant provisions before the individual leaves.
Depending on the contract, restrictions may cover:
- Working for a competitor
- Soliciting customers
- Dealing with customers
- Recruiting employees
- Using confidential information.
Employers should also consider practical protections such as restricting access to sensitive systems, recovering company devices and ensuring confidential documents are returned.
Consider garden leave
Where permitted by the employment contract, garden leave can sometimes help manage the transition.
The director remains employed and continues to receive pay but may be required to stay away from the workplace and avoid contact with customers or employees.
This can give the company time to transfer client relationships, responsibilities and commercially sensitive information before the individual joins another business.
Keep Companies House and corporate records up to date
Once a director resigns or is removed, Companies House must be notified.
Companies are generally required to report changes involving directors within 14 days.
Plan communications carefully
A senior departure can create uncertainty among employees, customers and commercial partners.
The business should consider in advance:
- What will be communicated internally
- Whether customers or suppliers need to be informed
- Who will take over responsibilities
- How the departure will be described publicly
- Whether an agreed announcement forms part of the exit terms.
Clear and controlled communication can help reduce disruption and protect the reputation of both the business and the departing individual.
Seek advice early
Director and shareholder exits can become difficult where employment, corporate ownership and personal relationships overlap.
Addressing each element separately but as part of a coordinated strategy can help prevent gaps and unexpected consequences.
DTM Legal’s Employment & HR team works alongside our Corporate & Commercial and Dispute Resolution specialists to advise businesses on director and shareholder disputes and exits, including employment termination, settlement agreements, restrictive covenants, share transfers and negotiated departures.
If your business is considering the exit of a director or shareholder, or a senior relationship has begun to break down, contact DTM Legal to discuss the options available.